Have you ever walked away from a conversation, replaying your words—wincing at how blunt, dismissive, or overly critical you sounded? Or maybe you didn’t say the words out loud, but you thought them—quiet judgments about someone’s choices, maturity, lifestyle, appearance, or spiritual walk.
Most of us don’t like to think of ourselves as judgmental. Yet one of the quickest ways the enemy sabotages the fruit of kindness in our lives is by planting subtle seeds of criticism. These seeds grow quietly—in expectations, comparisons, insecurities, and disappointments—until they begin shaping the way we speak, react, and relate to others.
A critical spirit doesn’t announce itself boldly. It whispers. It rationalizes. It disguises itself as “discernment,” “concern,” or “I’m just being honest.” And before long, it becomes the enemy of everything kindness is meant to cultivate: compassion, mercy, empathy, understanding, and grace.
So how can we recognize when this toxic root is growing in us? Scripture gives us two compelling pictures—one religious and proud, the other redeemed and still learning.
Let’s begin with the group Jesus confronted most directly: the Pharisees and scribes.
The Pharisees were the religious elite of their day: guardians of tradition, teachers of the law, spiritual influencers who shaped societal expectations. Yet Jesus regularly rebuked them not for their doctrine, but for their hearts.
He called them a “brood of vipers,” exposing a devastating truth about them:
“How can you speak good, when you are evil? For out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks” (Matthew 12:34 ESV).
What overflowed from their hearts?
They loved rules more than people. They delighted more in exposing sin than in restoring sinners. Their judgment was not righteous judgment (John 7:24)—it was hypocritical, harsh, and rooted in pride.
A judgmental spirit…
This is why judgmentalism kills kindness—it is impossible to cultivate mercy while rehearsing another person’s failures.
And yet, even sincere believers fall into this trap. Just ask the apostle Peter.
Acts 10 gives us a stunning moment in church history: the first outpouring of the Holy Spirit on Gentiles. But at the center of the miracle stands a conflicted disciple—Peter.
Peter was passionate, devoted, and deeply committed to Jesus. And yet even he had prejudices that produced judgment rather than kindness.
In a rooftop vision, God lowered a sheet filled with animals considered unclean under Jewish law. When God commanded him to eat, Peter protested. God told him:
“Do not call anything impure that God has made clean” (Acts 10:15).
The vision wasn’t primarily about food; it was about people. Peter had judged Gentiles as unclean and unworthy of fellowship. He would have never willingly entered Cornelius’s house. He would have never imagined that the Holy Spirit would fall on “outsiders” the same way He fell at Pentecost.
Yet God confronted Peter’s inner critic, his unconscious biases, and his categories of who was “in” and who was “out.”
And when Peter finally saw the outpouring of the Spirit, he declared:
“I now realize how true it is that God does not show favoritism” (Acts 10:34 NIV).
Peter’s story shows that a judgmental spirit is not always loud or malicious. Sometimes it is simply unexamined tradition, unchallenged assumptions, or untested fears. Sometimes it is blindness we didn’t know we had.
Peter’s transformation is a hopeful reminder: even when judgmentalism has shaped our thinking for years, the Spirit can break it in a moment of revelation.
Here are some common indicators that you may be struggling with a critical spirit:
A judgmental spirit is not always loud, but it is always destructive—to relationships, to unity, and to the fruit of kindness God wants to grow in us.
Here are practical, Spirit-led steps for transformation:
Admit your struggle without shame. Kindness begins where pride ends.
James tells us to be “quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry” (James 1:19). Listening creates space for kindness to breathe.
Ask questions instead of forming conclusions. Say things like:
Curiosity breaks the spine of judgment.
Romans 12 says, “Bless those who persecute you… do not curse.”
When critical thoughts arise, speak life instead:
You cannot bless and judge at the same time.
Jesus’s teaching is not about avoiding discernment—it is about avoiding hypocrisy. Examine yourself and your heart first before rebuking a brother or sister.
A judgmental spirit destroys the witness of Christ in us. But kindness—real, Spirit-born, truth-filled kindness—creates room for transformation. Pray for it intentionally: “Holy Spirit, soften my tone, cleanse my thoughts, and make me slow to judge and quick to love.”
✒️ REFLECT AND WRITE
Where do I sense the Holy Spirit gently convicting me about my tone, assumptions, or attitudes—and how can I partner with Him to respond in love?
Coming Up: Next week, we will unpack an important aspect of Christ’s kindness that we all need to emulate—extending forgiveness and mercy. 🩶
Do you want to learn how to walk in freedom and cultivate God’s kindness in your own life?
Learn more about the fruit of kindness and explore additional thought-provoking posts on our Fruit of Faith Blog. Interested in going deeper in your faith? Consider joining our BibleSpot S.T.A.R.s Discipleship Program, a 90-day intensive study and coaching program beginning in early 2026. We hope to be an encouraging part of your spiritual journey!
God's Word. Your Victory.